Vegetarian Talk

Vegetarian news, meatless recipes, and all things vegan!

You are here

Is Veganism More Ethical?

Replies

Andreas's picture
Submitted by Andreas on

I didn't really understand the better reasons for ethical veganism until after I made the transition. I was a vegetarian and wasn't comfortable investing my money in an industry I saw as to closely tied to the meat industry, but I still had a pretty rosy idea of life egg and dairy farms.

But since you seem to have worked on one of the more ethical types of farms, I'm curious how it handled the usual problems:

When the cows grew up and their milk production slowed down/stopped, did you continue to take good care of them? A cow can live for 20-25 years, but a milk cow is usually sent to slaughter at 5-6. I personally don't see much ethical differece in wether one kills an animal for its resources or if one harvests them before killing it.

And what happened to the calves? A milk cow needs to be kept pregnant for most of her life to keep producing milk, and while the female calves are raised as new milk cows, the males are usually sent to slaughter. Their deaths is an integral part of the dairy industry and as much a part of the milk as the death of a pig is to the ham. As is the constant bereavement of the cows who keeps getting inseminated only to time and time again have their kids stolen from them shortly after birth.

And of course, even for each happy egg laying hen, where they exist, there's usually a male sibling that has been thrown in the grinder since he donesn't profit the industry.

Sorry if it came out preachy. This are some of my main problems with the industry at the moment, and I'm genuinely curious as to how a farm with ethical ambitions handled these dilemmas.

As for restaurants, yes, vegan choices are rare. Though from my perspective the big picture is much more important than following a dogm, and making exceptions for the lacto-/ovo-vegetarian choices on the menu when vegan choices are lacking is to me much preferable than just deciding that going vegan is too hard.

laika.yaz's picture

Hi Andreas. Thanks for your thoughtful response.

The farm I worked with was primarily a dairy farm, but did also raise a few animals for meat. As far as the lives of the animals, the farm was an ethical one. All their animals enjoyed roaming pastures during their lifetimes. They received no hormonal injections and were kept healthy. When the time came for slaughter, they were brought to a slaughterhouse that said a prayer for the animal and thanked it for its sacrifice before killing it humanely. It's still a violent act, which I don't personally condone, but I have infinitely more respect for a farm that honors the lives of its animals even if they do ultimately end prematurely. Because they were working on such a small scale, there was nothing approaching the brutality of factory farms.

I'm uncomfortable with the violence even of humane slaughter, so I won't eat meat no matter how comfortable the animal was during its lifetime. However, I believe that people who do eat meat ought to procure it from places where animals are treated like sentient beings during their lifetime. I don't have as much of a problem with meat production so long as there's a sense of respect for the animals. The farm I spent time on had great respect for the animals they raised in life and in death.

Of course, it's rare to know whether your average grocery store milk and eggs come from such a place. I suppose the only situation where I could ethically consume animal products would be in a farming community where I was well acquainted with the harvesting practices and could verify they were humane. It sounds like you're of the opinion that there's no real way to farm animals without some degree of suffering involved, and so animal resources can't be harvested ethically at all. I guess I'm looking at the issue in a relative sense. I'm not sure that giving an animal a good life makes up for its eventual slaughter, but it's a step in the right direction from the current state of the industry. Like you said, the big picture is what counts at this point.

biggirlsdontfry's picture

I can;t believe the difference in cost for eating healthy/organic, as opposed to just buying crap. Should be more affordable to do the right thing!

Leave a Reply

Filtered HTML

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <ul> <ol> <li> <i> <b> <img> <table> <tr> <td> <th> <div> <strong> <p> <br> <u>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.